Login

Create an account

Welcome Aboard!

Free account required
For Sale
Listed on September 23, 2025

74560 Overseas Hwy

$3,999,000
0 Beds
0 Baths
6,071 sqft
15 Parkings
Lot size
-
Annual Tax
$18,004
Occupancy
Tenant
Year Built
1983
Property type
Multifamily
#MLS
A11883039

Description

Investor or Developer Opportunity in the Heart of Islamorada! This waterfront property features 8 income-producing units in excellent condition, including seven 1-bedroom/1-bath units and one penthouse 3-bedroom/2-bath unit. All units are currently leased, offering immediate cash flow. Enjoy ample parking, a premium location directly on Overseas Highway, and frontage to the water — a rare find in such a central area. Zoning allows for multiple possibilities. Whether you're looking to expand, redevelop, or simply enjoy stable income, this property is a must-see in the Florida Keys. Walking distance to restaurants, shops, marinas, and more.

Dacor Realty LLC

Features & Details

Learn about the features and details of 74560 Overseas Hwy

Property Details

  • Property Type
    Quadruplex
  • Living Area
    6,071 sqft
  • Year Built
    1983
  • Lot Size
    -
  • Stories
    -
  • Annual Tax
    $18,004.00
  • List Date
    9/23/2025
  • Updated
    10/2/2025
  • Last Checked
    Recent
  • MLS Number
    #A11883039
  • Brokerage
    Dacor Realty LLC
  • Postal Code
    33036
  • Area
    Monroe
  • City
    -

Additional Property Features

  • Occupancy
    Tenant
  • List Price
    $3,999,000.00
  • Unit Number
    -
  • Construction
    Brick,Block
  • Heating
    None
  • Fireplaces
    -
  • Garage
    -
  • Parking Type
    No
  • Pets Allowed
    No
  • Air Conditioning
    Ceiling Fans, Electric
  • Elevator
    No
  • Locker
    No
  • Swimming Pool
    None
  • Patio
    No
  • Basement
    No
  • Den
    No
  • Central Vacuum
    No
  • Garage Type
    No

Additional Listing Information

  • Walk Score
  • Property Manager
    -
  • Utilities Included
    None
  • Furnished
    No
  • Assessment Year
    2025
  • Assignment
    No
  • Extras Included
    None

Inside

  • Bedrooms & Baths
    0 Bed, 0 Bath
  • Ensuite
    Yes
  • Bathrooms
    0
  • Flooring
    Mixed

Price history

Learn about the price history of 74560 Overseas Hwy

Real estate trends

View trends of price in Miami over the last 12 months

Explore Monroe

Learn about the area around 74560 Overseas Hwy

Mortgage Calculator
Estimate monthly payments for 74560 Overseas Hwy
$0
20.0%
$3,999,000
1%
5.25%
10%
Estimated Monthly Payment

$19,171

Cash Flow Analysis
Mortgage Payment:
$19,171.13
Monthly Payment:
$20,671.47
Break Even Down Payment:
100%
Cash Flow
$0
Disclaimer: This calculator provides estimates for informational purposes only. Consult a financial advisor for personalized advice.

Similar listings

Shop homes for sale similar to 74560 Overseas Hwy, Monroe

Listed 11 days ago
74560 Overseas Hwy - 1
$3,999,000
Quadruplex
74560 Overseas Hwy
0
bed
0
ba
15
p
6071 sqft
Dacor Realty LLC
Listed 1 month ago
1115 Euclid Ave - 1
$4,340,000
Quadruplex
1115 Euclid Ave
0
bed
0
ba
0
p
8860 sqft
Dalan Realty, LLC
Listed 2 months ago
1037 NW 2nd St - 1
$3,900,000
Quadruplex
1037 NW 2nd St
0
bed
0
ba
7
p
7000 sqft
Keller Williams Capital Realty
Listed 2 months ago
17400 SW SW 296 Street - 1
$3,600,000
MultiFamily
17400 SW SW 296 Street
0
bed
0
ba
0
p
0 sqft
New Miami Realty
Listed 2 months ago
97 NW 27th St - 1
$4,250,000
Duplex
97 NW 27th St
0
bed
0
ba
0
p
5538 sqft
Gridline Properties
Listed 2 months ago
1040 94 street - 1
$3,799,999
Quadruplex
1040 94 street
0
bed
0
ba
10
p
4878 sqft
Citadel Realty

Similar Sold listings

Shop homes for sale similar to 74560 Overseas Hwy, Monroe

Sold 1 month ago
1362 SW 2nd St - 1
$3,900,000
$3,700,000
Quadruplex
1362 SW 2nd St
0
bed
0
ba
11
p
8019 sqft
BHHS EWM Realty
Sold 5 months ago
Image not found
$3,600,000
$3,425,000
Quadruplex
A11768034
0
bed
0
ba
15
p
10236 sqft
Property Pro Partners, LLC.
Sold 4 months ago
1815 Mckinley St - 1
$3,600,000
$3,300,000
Quadruplex
1815 Mckinley St
0
bed
0
ba
20
p
7476 sqft
LIV Real Estate Group
Sold 6 months ago
343 Madeira Ave - 1
$4,200,000
$4,200,000
Quadruplex
343 Madeira Ave
0
bed
0
ba
9
p
13636 sqft
Compass Florida, LLC.
Sold 16 months ago
2179 NW 18th Ter - 1
$3,700,000
$3,450,000
MultiFamily
2179 NW 18th Ter
0
bed
0
ba
0
p
0 sqft
Fausto Commercial Realty Consultants Inc
Sold 16 months ago
5979 NW 37th St - 1
$4,150,000
$3,850,000
Quadruplex
5979 NW 37th St
0
bed
0
ba
12
p
5508 sqft
Lokation

About this property

Discover this exceptional quadruplex in the heart of . This well-appointed property offers 6,071 square feet of living space. Originally built in 1983. Offered at $3,999,000.00 Don't miss this opportunity to own in one of the area's most desirable locations.

FAQs About 74560 Overseas Hwy

Miami Association of REALTORS®
Based on information from the Miami Association of REALTORS®. This information is for your personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties you may be interested in purchasing. Display of MLS data is usually deemed reliable but is NOT guaranteed accurate by the MLS. All properties are subject to prior sale or withdrawal. All information provided is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate, and should be independently verified. Unless otherwise specified in writing, Broker/Agent has not and will not verify any information.
©2025 Miami Association of REALTORS® all rights reserved.
74560 Overseas Hwy